Challenging Unlawful and Arbitrary Detention Under International Law
We help detained people and their families challenge detention that breaches Article 5 of the European Convention or Article 9 of the ICCPR – in domestic courts, in Strasbourg and before UN bodies.
Article 9 of the Universal Declaration of Human Rights states that "no one shall be subjected to arbitrary arrest, detention or exile". The same principle appears in binding treaty form in Article 9 of the International Covenant on Civil and Political Rights (ICCPR) and in Article 5 of the European Convention on Human Rights (ECHR). Our team acts for people who are detained, and for their families, combining domestic challenges with applications to the European Court of Human Rights and the UN mechanisms that deal with arbitrary detention.

Unlawful detention and arbitrary detention: not quite the same
Detention is unlawful when it has no basis in the law of the detaining State, or when the procedure that law prescribes was not followed. Article 5(1) ECHR permits deprivation of liberty only on listed grounds "and in accordance with a procedure prescribed by law", and ICCPR Article 9(1) allows it only on grounds and by procedures established by law.
Detention is arbitrary in the international sense in a wider set of situations. The UN Working Group on Arbitrary Detention (WGAD) works with five categories:
- detention with no legal basis at all, for example after the sentence has been served or despite an applicable amnesty;
- detention resulting from the exercise of protected rights, such as freedom of expression, religion, peaceful assembly and association (ICCPR Articles 18–19 and 21–22);
- detention following a trial so unfair that the detention itself becomes arbitrary;
- prolonged administrative custody of asylum seekers, immigrants or refugees without review or remedy;
- discriminatory detention, including on grounds of origin, religion, political opinion, gender, sexual orientation or disability.
A detention order can therefore look regular on paper and still be arbitrary under international standards.
Article 5 ECHR: grounds and safeguards in brief
Article 5(1) ECHR allows deprivation of liberty only in six listed cases — among them detention after conviction, arrest on reasonable suspicion of having committed an offence, and detention of a person against whom action is being taken with a view to deportation or extradition — and only "in accordance with a procedure prescribed by law". Detention that fits none of the grounds, or that was not ordered lawfully, breaches Article 5.
Every detained person is also entitled to be told the reasons promptly (Article 5(2)), to be brought promptly before a judge if held on suspicion of an offence (Article 5(3)), to a speedy court decision on the lawfulness of the detention (Article 5(4)) and to compensation for detention in breach of the Article (Article 5(5)). ICCPR Article 9 contains equivalent guarantees, including review "without delay". Our guide to Article 5 of the Convention explains each ground and safeguard in detail.
Detention pending extradition or deportation
A person held on an extradition request, or arrested abroad on an INTERPOL Red Notice, is usually detained under Article 5(1)(f), which covers a person "against whom action is being taken with a view to deportation or extradition". That ground is tied to the removal proceedings, and the person keeps the right to a speedy court review under Article 5(4). In Chahal v. the United Kingdom, a deportation case, the Court found violations of Article 5(4) and Article 13. Detention in these cases runs alongside arguments against the transfer itself, which is the focus of our work resisting extradition on human-rights grounds.
How we challenge unlawful detention
1. Domestic review with local counsel
International bodies expect the detaining State's own courts to be used first. The European Court requires domestic remedies to be exhausted "according to the generally recognised rules of international law", and the UN Human Rights Committee also requires exhaustion. We work with counsel admitted in the country of detention on applications for release, appeals against detention orders and other available forms of review, so that the Convention or Covenant argument is raised at home and preserved for later.
2. Application to the European Court of Human Rights
Where the detaining State is a party to the ECHR, a person claiming to be the victim of a violation may apply to the Court under Article 34. The time limit is four months from the final domestic decision. An Article 5 complaint can be combined with complaints under Article 6 (fair trial) or Article 3 (ill-treatment or conditions). The way we prepare and conduct these cases is set out on our page about applications to the European Court.
3. Rule 39 where removal is imminent
If a detained person faces imminent extradition or expulsion to a country where there is a real risk of irreparable harm, the Court may indicate interim measures under Rule 39. They are exceptional, require prima facie evidence of an imminent risk, and are not applied to prevent removal while a domestic remedy with suspensive effect is still open. A request must state the destination country and the expected removal date and enclose the related decisions – see our page on urgent Rule 39 interim measures.
4. Petition to the UN Working Group on Arbitrary Detention
The WGAD's mandate is "to investigate cases of deprivation of liberty imposed arbitrarily". Communications may come from the detained person, the family or a representative, and its Methods of Work contain no requirement to exhaust domestic remedies. The Government is asked to reply within 60 days, extendable by up to one month, and the WGAD may render its opinion even without a reply. Where continued detention seriously threatens health or life, urgent action can be requested. We explain the procedure on our UN Working Group on Arbitrary Detention page.
5. Complaint to the UN Human Rights Committee
If the detaining State has accepted the First Optional Protocol to the ICCPR, a breach of Article 9 can be brought before the Human Rights Committee once domestic remedies are exhausted. The Committee will not consider a matter that is being examined under another international procedure, and several European States have reservations excluding matters already considered elsewhere, so the choice between Strasbourg and Geneva has to be made early. The United Kingdom is not a party to the Protocol, so detention in the UK cannot be brought before the Committee. The admissibility rules are covered on our page on individual complaints to the Human Rights Committee.
How we help – and what to send us first
A first review is more useful when we can see the documents rather than a summary. If you can, send:
- the arrest record and every detention order, with dates;
- the charges, the extradition request or the Red Notice details, if any;
- court decisions on detention and any appeals, including those still pending;
- information on the place and conditions of detention and on the detained person's health;
- if removal is planned, the destination country and the expected date;
- details of any local counsel already acting, and who can sign an authority on the detained person's behalf.
We then review which grounds of Article 5 or ICCPR Article 9 are engaged, which domestic steps remain open, which time limits are running, and which international forum fits the case, taking into account the rules that restrict parallel international procedures. We prepare the domestic arguments with local counsel, the international application or communication, and any urgent request. Family members may contact us on the detained person's behalf through the form, WhatsApp, Telegram or email.
Frequently Asked Questions
Not necessarily. Article 5 requires both a permitted ground and a procedure prescribed by law, and a court order does not cure a missing ground. Internationally, the WGAD also regards detention as arbitrary where it punishes the exercise of protected rights, follows a grossly unfair trial or is discriminatory. A court order is where the analysis starts, not where it ends.
Yes, within limits. The WGAD accepts communications from the detained person's family or representatives. Before the European Court, the applicant is the detained person, and a representative needs a signed authority, so relatives usually gather documents and help arrange that authority. We can take first instructions from relatives and then confirm them with the person in detention.
Article 5(5) ECHR and ICCPR Article 9(5) both give an enforceable right to compensation for detention in breach of those provisions. If the European Court finds a violation and domestic law allows only partial reparation, it may award just satisfaction under Article 41, but the applicant must submit a specific, itemised claim within the time limit set, or the claim may be rejected.
The WGAD renders opinions on whether a detention is arbitrary and makes recommendations to the Government. The opinion is sent to the Government, then to the source 48 hours later, and is published and reported to the Human Rights Council. It is not a court order, so how it is used afterwards – including in domestic release applications – matters.
No. The UK is not a party to the First Optional Protocol to the ICCPR, so the Human Rights Committee cannot receive complaints against it, and the UK has not made the Article 22 declaration needed for individual complaints to the Committee against Torture. The European Court of Human Rights and the WGAD procedure are the international options to assess.
Before the European Court, four months from the final domestic decision. Before the Human Rights Committee, a communication filed five years after exhaustion of domestic remedies may be treated as an abuse unless the delay is justified. The WGAD's Methods of Work set no exhaustion requirement, but an earlier filing usually means the facts are fresher and easier to document.