Filing an Individual Complaint with the UN Human Rights Committee

If your State has accepted the right of individual complaint, the UN Human Rights Committee – or, for torture risks, the Committee against Torture – can examine your case. We assess eligibility and prepare the communication.

Send Us a Message
Human Rights Lawyers team

An international human rights complaint is usually the last step after the national courts have failed to put a violation right. In Europe, most people think first of the European Court of Human Rights. The United Nations treaty bodies offer a second route: the Human Rights Committee examines individual complaints, called "communications", under the International Covenant on Civil and Political Rights (ICCPR), and the Committee against Torture examines complaints under the Convention against Torture (CAT). Both procedures depend on whether the State concerned has accepted them, and both have admissibility rules that interact with Strasbourg. Our team is independent of the UN; we advise on whether a complaint is possible and prepare it.

Delegate desks in the Assembly Hall of the Palais des Nations, Geneva
Photo: Nick-D, CC BY-SA 4.0, via Wikimedia Commons; cropped.

Who can file a complaint with the Human Rights Committee

The First Optional Protocol to the ICCPR allows individuals who claim to be victims of a violation of a Covenant right, and who "have exhausted all available domestic remedies", to submit written communications to the Committee. Only communications against States that are parties to the Protocol are received. The Protocol has 116 parties.

The United Kingdom is not a party to the First Optional Protocol. A complaint against the UK therefore cannot be brought before the Human Rights Committee, whatever Covenant right is involved.

The Covenant rights often relevant in our work include the prohibition of arbitrary arrest or detention in Article 9 and the right to a "fair and public hearing by a competent, independent and impartial tribunal established by law" in Article 14(1). If the problem is detention, the UN Working Group on Arbitrary Detention is a separate option with different rules – see our page on petitions to the Working Group on Arbitrary Detention.

Admissibility: the conditions that decide most cases

  • Exhaustion of domestic remedies. Available domestic remedies must be exhausted first. This is not required where their application is "unreasonably prolonged".
  • No parallel international procedure. The Committee will not consider a communication if the same matter "is being examined under another procedure of international investigation or settlement".
  • European reservations. Several European States, France and Germany among them, have made reservations excluding matters "already considered under another procedure of international investigation or settlement". For those States, a case already decided in Strasbourg may be closed to the Committee.
  • Timing. The Protocol sets no four-month rule, but under Rule 99(c) of the Committee's rules of procedure a communication may be an abuse of the right of submission if it is filed five years after exhaustion of domestic remedies, or three years after the end of another international procedure, unless the delay is justified.

Interim measures under Rule 94

After a communication is registered, the Committee may ask the State to take urgent interim measures "to avoid possible actions which could have irreparable consequences" for the author. Under Rule 94 of the rules of procedure, non-implementation of such a request is "incompatible with the obligation to respect in good faith" the Optional Protocol procedure. They matter in particular where a person is about to be removed to a country where he or she faces serious harm.

Torture and removal: the Committee against Torture

Article 3(1) CAT prohibits any State party from expelling, returning ("refouler") or extraditing a person where there are substantial grounds for believing that he or she would be in danger of being subjected to torture. Under Article 3(2), the authorities must take into account any "consistent pattern of gross, flagrant or mass violations of human rights" in the destination State. This protection has no exception for the person's conduct.

An individual complaint to the Committee against Torture is possible only against a State that has made a declaration under Article 22 CAT. Domestic remedies must be exhausted, unless they are unreasonably prolonged or unlikely to bring effective relief, and the same matter must not be under examination in another international procedure. Under Rule 114 of its rules, the Committee may request interim measures "to avoid irreparable damage", on the basis of the complainant's submission alone. CAT has 176 parties, but the United Kingdom has made no Article 22 declaration, so individual complaints against the UK cannot go to CAT either. Removal cases of this kind connect closely with our work on asylum and protection from refoulement and on human-rights defences to extradition.

Strasbourg or Geneva?

For a person in a Council of Europe State that has also accepted the UN procedures, the forum has to be chosen with care, because each system restricts parallel complaints.

European Court of Human RightsUN Human Rights Committee
Who can be complained againstStates party to the ECHRStates party to the First Optional Protocol (116; not the UK)
Time limitFour months from the final domestic decisionNo fixed limit; risk of abuse finding after five years (Rule 99(c))
Parallel proceduresRejects a matter substantially the same as one already submitted to another international procedure, unless new informationWill not consider a matter being examined elsewhere; reservations of some European States also exclude matters already considered
Urgent measuresRule 39 interim measures, binding on the StateRule 94 interim measures after registration

Practical factors also count: whether the four-month deadline in Strasbourg has already passed, whether the State concerned is a party to the ECHR at all, and whether the complaint concerns a Covenant right with no direct equivalent in the Convention. Where removal is imminent, the scope of Rule 39 interim measures in Strasbourg is compared with Rule 94 or CAT Rule 114 before any request is sent. Our page on applications to the European Court explains the Strasbourg route.

What we prepare

A communication to a UN treaty body is a written case: the Committee decides on the documents. Our work covers:

  • checking whether the State has accepted the relevant procedure, and any reservations it has made;
  • confirming that domestic remedies have been exhausted, or documenting why they are unreasonably prolonged or ineffective;
  • identifying the Covenant or CAT articles engaged and the evidence for each complaint;
  • checking that the same matter is not, and has not been, before another international body in a way that bars the complaint;
  • drafting the communication and, where needed, a request for interim measures;
  • following the case after submission and keeping you informed.

To begin, send us the final domestic decision, earlier judgments and appeals, any decision on removal with the planned date, and a note of any application already made to the European Court or another international body.

Frequently Asked Questions

No. The Human Rights Committee can receive communications only against States that are parties to the First Optional Protocol to the ICCPR, of which there are 116. Complaints to the Committee against Torture are possible only against States that have made a declaration under Article 22 CAT. Checking the State's status is the first step.

The UK is not a party to the First Optional Protocol, so the Human Rights Committee cannot receive individual communications against it. The UK's declaration under the Convention against Torture covers only inter-State complaints under Article 21, not individual complaints under Article 22. For people in the UK, the European Court of Human Rights remains the international route for most complaints.

Usually not about the same matter. The Committee will not consider a matter being examined under another international procedure, several European States have reservations excluding matters already considered, and the European Court rejects applications substantially the same as a matter already submitted elsewhere unless there is new information. Different matters may go to different bodies.

The Optional Protocol has no four-month rule like Strasbourg's. However, under Rule 99(c) the Committee may treat a communication as an abuse if it is submitted five years after exhaustion of domestic remedies, or three years after another international procedure ended, unless the delay is justified. Filing well within those periods avoids the argument.

Article 3 CAT prohibits removal where there are substantial grounds for believing a person would be in danger of torture. If the State has made an Article 22 declaration, the Committee against Torture can request interim measures on the complainant's submission alone. The Human Rights Committee and, in Europe, the European Court have their own urgent procedures, so the choice must be made quickly.