Challenging an INTERPOL Red Notice on Human Rights Grounds
A Red Notice asks for a wanted person to be located and arrested with a view to extradition. We test it against INTERPOL's rules, prepare requests to the CCF and coordinate them with extradition and asylum proceedings.
A Red Notice is a request circulated through INTERPOL that seeks the location of a wanted person and his or her "detention, arrest or restriction of movement for the purpose of extradition, surrender, or similar lawful action". It is published by INTERPOL's General Secretariat and must refer to a valid arrest warrant or equivalent judicial decision from the requesting country; it is not a decision of a court in the country where you live. We are an independent firm with no affiliation to INTERPOL or to its Commission for the Control of Files (CCF). Our work is to test whether a notice complies with INTERPOL's own rules and with international human-rights law, and to bring that challenge in the forums where it matters.

The legal limits on INTERPOL: Articles 2 and 3 of the Constitution
Article 2(1) of the INTERPOL Constitution sets mutual assistance between police authorities as an aim to be pursued "in the spirit of the 'Universal Declaration of Human Rights'". Article 3 states: "It is strictly forbidden for the Organization to undertake any intervention or activities of a political, military, religious or racial character."
INTERPOL applies Article 3 through a "predominance" test that dates back to a 1951 General Assembly resolution. Requests are excluded for offences "of a predominantly political, racial or religious character … even if – in the requesting country – the facts amount to an offence against the ordinary law". To assess compliance, the Rules on the Processing of Data (RPD) list the elements to be examined:
- the nature of the offence;
- the status of the persons concerned;
- the source of the data;
- the positions of other National Central Bureaus;
- obligations under international law;
- implications for INTERPOL's neutrality;
- the general context.
A politically motivated request will not describe itself as political: it will describe an offence against the ordinary law. That is exactly the situation the predominance test addresses. It asks what the case is really about, which is why context, timing and the status of the person concerned carry so much weight.
Minimum criteria for a Red Notice under RPD Article 83
Even where Article 3 is not engaged, a Red Notice must meet minimum criteria. Under Article 83(1)(a) RPD:
- Offence: it must be a "serious ordinary-law crime". Red Notices are excluded for offences raising controversial behavioural or cultural issues, family or private matters, and administrative or private-dispute offences, unless linked to serious or organised crime.
- Penalty threshold for prosecution: a maximum penalty of at least two years' deprivation of liberty.
- Penalty threshold for a sentence: a sentence of at least six months, or at least six months still to serve.
- Interest: the request must be of interest for international police cooperation.
The General Secretariat may publish a notice below the offence or penalty thresholds if it is "of particular importance to international police cooperation". The notice also requires minimum identity data and judicial data, including a reference to a valid arrest warrant or equivalent judicial decision. A commercial dispute recast as a criminal case, or a notice that rests on a warrant no longer in force, can fail on these grounds alone.
Refugees and people protected from return
INTERPOL's Repository of Practice treats a request from the "country of origin" concerning a refugee protected vis-à-vis that country as tainting the whole request and preventing the use of INTERPOL's channels. The same applies where a competent national body has found that extradition would breach non-refoulement. If you have refugee status or a protection decision, it belongs at the centre of a CCF file, and we coordinate closely with our work on refugee status and international protection.
Which human rights a Red Notice engages
A notice can lead to arrest and detention pending extradition (Article 5 ECHR), to surrender to a State where there is a real risk of ill-treatment (Article 3) or a flagrant denial of justice (Article 6), and to serious interference with private and family life (Article 8). Our guide on human rights a Red Notice engages explains each of these in turn. On this page we focus on what we do about it.
Requests to the Commission for the Control of Files
The Statute of the CCF provides in Article 4 that "the Commission shall be independent in the performance of its functions". Under Article 29, any person may request access to, or correction or deletion of, data about them directly from the CCF. Under Article 30(3), there is no charge for this.
Access requests and deletion requests
An access request asks the CCF to confirm whether INTERPOL holds data on you and to disclose it, subject to the Statute's rules. It is often the first step where you suspect a notice exists but have not seen it. A deletion request asks the CCF to find that the data does not comply with INTERPOL's rules and should be removed. It is built around Articles 2 and 3 of the Constitution, the RPD criteria, the refugee policy and the evidence on the human-rights risks you face. In some cases the two are combined, or a request for correction is more appropriate than deletion.
Deadlines under the CCF Statute
- Admissibility: you are told whether the request is admissible "no later than one month" from receipt (Article 32(1)).
- Access requests: decided within four months of admissibility (Article 40(1)).
- Correction or deletion requests: decided within nine months of admissibility (Article 40(2)).
- Extensions: possible where they are "reasonable" and explained (Article 40(3)).
Provisional measures, binding decisions and revision
The CCF may order provisional measures at any time (Article 37), which matters when an arrest or extradition hearing is approaching. Its decisions "shall be final and binding on the Organization and the applicant" (Article 38(1)), and the General Secretariat must implement a decision within one month of receiving it (Article 41(2)). There is no appeal. Revision is possible only on the discovery of new facts, and the application must be made within six months of that discovery (Article 42). This is why the first submission must be complete: the arguments and evidence you do not put forward at the outset may not be heard later.
Coordinating the CCF with extradition and asylum proceedings
A Red Notice is a means to an end: arrest with a view to extradition. The CCF examines compliance with INTERPOL's rules, while a national extradition court applies its own law, on its own procedure and timetable. The two tracks therefore have to be run together. Human-rights bars raised in court, such as a real risk of ill-treatment or extraneous considerations, are often the same facts that show a notice breaches Article 3 of the Constitution. We handle both, including resisting extradition on human-rights grounds and, where removal is imminent, urgent Rule 39 interim measures before the European Court of Human Rights. Where the allegations behind a notice have also been used to justify an asset freeze, the same evidence serves both cases, and we run sanctions delisting and asset-freeze challenges alongside the CCF request.
What we prepare and what to send us
- What we review: whether a notice exists and what it says, the arrest warrant and the criminal case behind it, the RPD thresholds, the political context, your refugee or protection status, and any pending extradition proceedings.
- What we prepare: access requests, correction or deletion requests with supporting evidence, requests for provisional measures, follow-up submissions while the CCF examines the file, and, where needed, applications for revision based on new facts.
- What to send first: any notice or arrest document you have seen, the domestic charge sheet or judgment, records of the underlying dispute, refugee or asylum decisions, and details of any arrest, detention or extradition hearing, with dates.
Frequently Asked Questions
No. Article 30(3) of the CCF Statute provides that there is no charge for requests to access, correct or delete data. Professional representation is a separate matter between you and your lawyers, but the CCF procedure itself is free of charge to the person concerned.
You can ask. Article 29 of the CCF Statute gives any person the right to request access to data about them, and the CCF decides what can be disclosed under the Statute's rules. Admissibility should be confirmed within one month of receipt, and the access request decided within four months of admissibility, unless the CCF extends the period for reasons it explains. An access request is often the first step before a deletion request.
INTERPOL's rules exclude Red Notices for family or private matters and for administrative or private-dispute offences, unless the offence is linked to serious or organised crime. Where a business conflict has been turned into a criminal complaint, the documents showing the commercial origin of the case are central to the argument.
No. CCF decisions are final and binding on INTERPOL and the applicant. The only route back is revision, which requires the discovery of new facts and an application within six months of discovering them. This is why a deletion request should present all available arguments and evidence from the outset.
INTERPOL's Repository of Practice treats a request from the country of origin concerning a refugee protected against that country as preventing the use of INTERPOL's channels. The same applies where a national body has found that extradition would breach non-refoulement. Refugee and protection decisions should therefore be placed before the CCF.