Article 5 of the European Convention: The Right to Liberty

Article 5 sets the only grounds on which a State may lock someone up and the safeguards that follow any arrest. This guide explains each part and how breaches are argued.

Send Us a Message
Human Rights Lawyers team

Article 5 ECHR — Article 5 of the European Convention on Human Rights — opens with a simple statement: "Everyone has the right to liberty and security of person." The rest of the article explains when that right may be taken away and what protection a detained person keeps. It applies to every form of detention by a State party – police custody, pre-trial detention, imprisonment after conviction, psychiatric detention, immigration detention and detention pending extradition.

Barred window of an old fortress prison

Article 5 ECHR: the structure of the right to liberty

The article has five paragraphs, each doing a different job:

  • Article 5(1) lists the only cases in which a person may be deprived of liberty, and requires that this happens "in accordance with a procedure prescribed by law".
  • Article 5(2) requires that anyone arrested is told promptly, in a language he or she understands, the reasons for the arrest and any charge.
  • Article 5(3) protects people arrested on suspicion of an offence: prompt production before a judge, and trial within a reasonable time or release pending trial.
  • Article 5(4) gives every detained person the right to have a court decide "speedily" whether the detention is lawful.
  • Article 5(5) gives "an enforceable right to compensation" for detention in breach of the article.

The full text is in the official text of the Convention published by the Court.

Two conditions for any detention

Article 5(1) sets two cumulative conditions. First, the detention must fall within one of the grounds in sub-paragraphs (a) to (f); the words "save in the following cases" make that list closed. Second, it must be carried out "in accordance with a procedure prescribed by law", and each ground itself speaks of "lawful" arrest or detention. A detention can therefore breach Article 5 in two different ways: because it fits no permitted ground, or because domestic law and procedure were not respected.

The six permitted grounds

(a) After conviction

The lawful detention of a person after conviction by a competent court. This covers serving a sentence; questions about the fairness of the trial itself belong mainly to Article 6.

(b) Court orders and legal obligations

Arrest or detention for non-compliance with the lawful order of a court, or to secure the fulfilment of an obligation prescribed by law.

(c) Suspicion of an offence

Arrest or detention to bring a person before the competent legal authority on reasonable suspicion of having committed an offence, or when reasonably considered necessary to prevent an offence or flight after one. This is the ground for police custody and pre-trial detention, and it is the only ground linked to the extra safeguards in Article 5(3).

(d) Minors

Detention of a minor by lawful order for the purpose of educational supervision, or to bring the minor before the competent legal authority.

(e) Health and social grounds

Detention to prevent the spreading of infectious diseases, and detention of persons of unsound mind, alcoholics, drug addicts or vagrants.

(f) Immigration, deportation and extradition

Arrest or detention to prevent unauthorised entry into the country, or of a person "against whom action is being taken with a view to deportation or extradition". This ground is discussed separately below.

Procedural safeguards after arrest

Reasons for the arrest – Article 5(2)

The person must be informed promptly of the reasons for the arrest and of any charge, in a language he or she understands. Without reasons, the person cannot challenge the detention effectively. The same requirement appears in Principle 10 of the UN Body of Principles on detention, which requires reasons at the time of arrest.

Prompt judicial control – Article 5(3)

Anyone held under Article 5(1)(c) must be brought "promptly" before a judge or other officer authorised by law to exercise judicial power. He or she is then entitled to trial within a reasonable time or to release pending trial. In the UN system, Article 9(3) of the International Covenant on Civil and Political Rights (ICCPR) adds that pre-trial detention "shall not be the general rule".

Speedy review by a court – Article 5(4)

Article 5(4) applies to everyone deprived of liberty, whatever the ground. The person must be able to take proceedings in which a court decides the lawfulness of the detention "speedily" and orders release if the detention is not lawful. In Chahal v. the United Kingdom, a deportation case, the Court found a violation of Article 5(4) together with Article 13.

Compensation – Article 5(5)

A person detained in breach of any part of Article 5 has "an enforceable right to compensation". This is a right that should be available in domestic law. If the European Court finds a violation and domestic law allows only partial reparation, it may also award just satisfaction under Article 41, provided the applicant makes a specific, itemised claim in time.

Detention for extradition and deportation

Article 5(1)(f) is the ground used when a person is held while removal proceedings run – including after an arrest on an INTERPOL Red Notice, which seeks the location of a wanted person and his or her detention or arrest "for the purpose of extradition, surrender, or similar lawful action". The wording ties the detention to action being taken "with a view to deportation or extradition", and the Article 5(4) right to speedy court review applies throughout. Arguments about the detention usually sit alongside arguments that the removal itself would breach Article 3 or Article 6, which is the focus of a human-rights defence to extradition. Where the arrest stems from a Red Notice, the notice itself can be challenged separately – see our page on challenging Red Notices on human-rights grounds.

Can Article 5 be suspended?

Article 5 is not among the provisions protected from derogation by Article 15(2), which covers Articles 2 (except deaths from lawful acts of war), 3, 4(1) and 7. A State may therefore derogate from Article 5 "in time of war or other public emergency threatening the life of the nation", but only to the extent strictly required by the situation, and it must keep the Secretary General of the Council of Europe informed.

Article 5 and UN standards on arbitrary detention

Article 5 has close counterparts in international law. Article 9 of the Universal Declaration of Human Rights provides that "no one shall be subjected to arbitrary arrest, detention or exile", and ICCPR Article 9 contains rights to court review "without delay" and to compensation. The UN Working Group on Arbitrary Detention applies these standards to individual cases through its five categories of arbitrary detention, without requiring domestic remedies to be exhausted – see our page on petitions to the Working Group on Arbitrary Detention.

How an Article 5 violation is argued

Complaints under Article 5 tend to follow the structure of the article itself. The questions are usually these:

  1. Was there a deprivation of liberty? The facts of the confinement – where, for how long, under whose control – are set out first.
  2. Which ground did the authorities rely on? The detention order should name a basis; the question is whether it truly fits one of grounds (a) to (f).
  3. Was it lawful? Domestic law and procedure are checked: who ordered the detention, under which provision, whether time limits were respected.
  4. Were the safeguards respected? Reasons under 5(2), prompt production before a judge under 5(3), a reasonable length of pre-trial detention, and a speedy court review under 5(4).
  5. Was compensation available? If domestic law offers no enforceable claim for detention in breach of Article 5, Article 5(5) is engaged.

Each point needs to be raised before the national courts first, because the Court requires domestic remedies to be exhausted; the conditions for a case to reach the merits are explained in our guide to ECHR admissibility criteria. For a current detention, practical help is available through our unlawful detention practice, and the Strasbourg stage is handled by our ECHR lawyer team.

Frequently Asked Questions

It protects the right to liberty and security of person. A State party may detain someone only on one of six grounds listed in Article 5(1) and in accordance with a procedure prescribed by law. Anyone detained also keeps procedural rights: reasons for the arrest, prompt judicial control if suspected of an offence, speedy court review, and compensation for unlawful detention.

Article 5 concerns deprivation of liberty by arrest or detention. Whether a particular restriction reaches that level depends on the facts of the confinement, such as where the person was held, for how long and under whose control. That factual description is the first point to establish in any Article 5 complaint.

Yes. Article 5(1)(f) covers detention to prevent unauthorised entry and detention of a person against whom action is being taken with a view to deportation or extradition. The right under Article 5(4) to have a court decide speedily on the lawfulness of the detention applies to these cases as well.

Article 5(3) applies only to people held on suspicion of an offence under Article 5(1)(c): they must be brought promptly before a judge and tried within a reasonable time or released pending trial. Article 5(4) applies to every detained person and gives a right to take court proceedings in which the lawfulness of detention is decided speedily.

Article 5(5) requires an enforceable right to compensation for detention in breach of Article 5. If the national system does not provide full reparation and the European Court finds a violation, it may award just satisfaction under Article 41, but only on a specific, itemised claim submitted within the time limit.