Resisting Extradition on Human Rights Grounds
When a State asks for your surrender, the question is not only whether the paperwork is in order. We assess whether extradition would expose you to ill-treatment, an unfair trial or persecution, and build the human-rights case against it.
Our extradition lawyers act for people whose surrender is requested by another State and who face ill-treatment, an unfair trial or persecution if they are sent there. We work alongside your defence in the extradition court, prepare the human-rights evidence and, where removal is imminent, take the urgent steps available before international bodies.

Extradition is a request by one State to another to surrender a person for prosecution or to serve a sentence. Courts first check formal conditions. Human-rights law adds a separate and often decisive question: would surrender expose you to treatment that the requested State is itself forbidden to inflict or to facilitate? That question can bar surrender even where every formal condition is met.
A real risk of torture or ill-treatment after surrender
Article 3 of the European Convention on Human Rights reads: "No one shall be subjected to torture or to inhuman or degrading treatment or punishment." It contains no exceptions, and Article 15(2) allows no derogation from it, even in a public emergency. In Soering v. the United Kingdom (1989), the European Court of Human Rights held that extradition may engage Article 3 "where substantial grounds have been shown for believing that the person concerned, if extradited, faces a real risk" of such treatment in the requesting country, and it found that extradition to the United States would violate Article 3 on the facts of that case. The Soering judgment remains the starting point for Article 3 arguments in extradition.
Two later Grand Chamber judgments explain why this protection does not bend. In Chahal v. the United Kingdom (1996), the Court said Article 3 is "equally absolute in expulsion cases" and that the individual's activities, "however undesirable or dangerous, cannot be a material consideration". In Saadi v. Italy (2008), it rejected the argument that the risk of ill-treatment can be weighed against the interests of the community. See our guide to the prohibition of torture and inhuman treatment.
Diplomatic assurances
Requesting States may answer an Article 3 argument with written assurances. In Saadi, the Court said assurances do not absolve it from examining whether they work in practice. In Othman (Abu Qatada) v. the United Kingdom (2012), assurances were accepted and no Article 3 violation was found. We therefore test each assurance: what it promises, who gives it, and whether it covers the specific risk you face.
Flagrant denial of justice: Article 6
Article 6(1) protects the right to a "fair and public hearing within a reasonable time by an independent and impartial tribunal established by law". The threshold for resisting removal is a "flagrant denial of justice". In Othman, the Court found that deportation to Jordan would violate Article 6 because of a real risk that evidence obtained by torture of third persons would be admitted at the retrial. Othman concerned deportation, but it is our reference point for fair-trial objections to extradition.
The death penalty and assurances against it
Under Article 11 of the European Convention on Extradition 1957, where the offence is punishable by death in the requesting State but not in the requested State, extradition may be refused unless sufficient assurance is given that the death penalty "will not be carried out". In the United Kingdom, section 94 of the Extradition Act 2003 provides that the Secretary of State must not order extradition to a category 2 territory where the person could be sentenced to death, unless an adequate written assurance is received that the sentence will not be imposed or carried out. Article 19(2) of the EU Charter of Fundamental Rights prohibits removal or extradition to a State where there is a serious risk of the death penalty, torture or other inhuman or degrading treatment.
Political offences and extraneous considerations
Article 3(1) of the European Convention on Extradition provides that extradition "shall not be granted" for an offence the requested Party regards as political or connected with a political offence. Article 3(2) extends this to requests made in order to prosecute or punish a person on account of race, religion, nationality or political opinion. The exception is not unlimited: under Article 3(3), taking or attempting to take the life of a Head of State or a member of his or her family is not a political offence.
UK law contains a parallel bar. Under sections 13 (Part 1) and 81 (Part 2) of the Extradition Act 2003, extradition is barred by "extraneous considerations" if the request is in fact made to prosecute or punish the person on account of race, religion, nationality, gender, sexual orientation or political opinions, or if he or she might be prejudiced at trial or punished on those grounds.
Convention rights, proportionality and health under the Extradition Act 2003
- Section 21A (Part 1, accused persons): the judge must decide whether extradition is compatible with Convention rights under the Human Rights Act 1998, and whether it would be disproportionate, considering the seriousness of the conduct, the likely penalty and less coercive alternatives.
- Section 21 (Part 1, convicted persons unlawfully at large): the test is compatibility with Convention rights.
- Section 87 (Part 2): the judge must decide whether extradition is compatible with Convention rights. If it is not, the person must be discharged; if it is, the case goes to the Secretary of State.
- Sections 25 and 91: if the person's physical or mental condition makes extradition "unjust or oppressive", the judge must discharge the person or adjourn the hearing.
The text of section 21A of the Extradition Act 2003 is on legislation.gov.uk. Convention rights here include the right to private and family life under Article 8, which is subject to the necessity test in Article 8(2). Detention pending extradition is itself regulated: Article 5(1)(f) ECHR permits detention of a person "against whom action is being taken with a view to deportation or extradition", and Article 5(4) requires that its lawfulness be decided "speedily by a court". Where detention becomes the main problem, we work on challenging unlawful detention alongside the extradition case.
The rule of speciality
Under Article 14 of the European Convention on Extradition, an extradited person may not be proceeded against, sentenced or detained for any other offence committed before surrender. There are two exceptions: the surrendering Party consents, or the person fails to leave the territory within 45 days of final discharge, or returns after leaving.
European arrest warrants: the Aranyosi two-step test
In Aranyosi and Căldăraru (2016), the EU Court of Justice set out a two-step test. First, there must be objective, reliable, specific and properly updated evidence of deficiencies in detention conditions. Second, the executing authority must determine "specifically and precisely" whether there are substantial grounds to believe the particular person faces a real risk of inhuman or degrading treatment under Article 4 of the Charter. It must request further information and postpone surrender; if the risk cannot be discounted within a reasonable time, it decides whether to end the procedure.
When removal is imminent: Rule 39
If domestic remedies are exhausted and surrender is about to take place, the European Court of Human Rights may indicate interim measures under Rule 39 of the Rules of Court "in exceptional circumstances", where there is an "imminent risk of irreparable harm to a Convention right". Interim measures are binding (Mamatkulov and Askarov v. Turkey). The Court will not apply Rule 39 to prevent removal while a domestic remedy with suspensive effect is still open, and requests received less than a working day before the scheduled removal may not be dealt with. We prepare urgent Rule 39 interim measures requests with the information the Practice Direction requires, including the destination and the expected removal date.
Coordinating extradition with the Red Notice and asylum
Extradition may follow an INTERPOL Red Notice, which seeks the location of a wanted person and his or her arrest "for the purpose of extradition, surrender, or similar lawful action". A request to INTERPOL's Commission for the Control of Files (CCF) runs separately and can seek provisional measures. We coordinate the two; see our work on challenging a Red Notice before the CCF. Where you are a recognised refugee or have a pending claim, protection from return is a core part of the defence, and our asylum and international protection practice is involved from the start. INTERPOL's Repository of Practice treats a request from the country of origin concerning a refugee protected vis-à-vis that country, or a request concerning a person whose extradition a competent national body has found would breach non-refoulement, as preventing use of INTERPOL's channels.
How we help when extradition is requested
We are an independent firm. Our role is to identify the human-rights bars that genuinely apply to your case and present them in the right forum. Where the same allegations have also led to a sanctions designation in the UK, the EU or the US, we coordinate the extradition defence with challenging the designation and asset freeze.
- What we review: the extradition request or warrant, the charges and the penalty, the prosecution in the requesting State, detention conditions, assurances, and your health and family position.
- What we prepare: written submissions on Articles 3, 6 and 8, extraneous considerations, the political offence exception, speciality and proportionality; requests for interim measures; parallel submissions to the CCF; and, where relevant, detention challenges.
- What to send first: the request or warrant and any court papers; anything you know about a Red Notice; documents from the criminal case in the requesting State; asylum or refugee decisions; medical records; and the date of any scheduled hearing or removal.
Frequently Asked Questions
Yes, in principle. Formal validity and human-rights compatibility are separate questions. Under the UK Extradition Act 2003, for example, the judge must decide whether surrender is compatible with Convention rights and, if it is not, must discharge the person. A real risk of ill-treatment, a flagrant denial of justice or persecution on protected grounds can each bar surrender regardless of how well the paperwork is drafted.
Not automatically. The European Court of Human Rights has said that assurances do not relieve it of the duty to examine whether they work in practice. In some cases assurances have been accepted, as in Othman on Article 3. The question is always whether a specific assurance, given by a specific authority, actually removes the specific risk you face.
The political offence exception looks at the nature of the offence itself. Extraneous considerations look at the motive behind the request and at how you would be treated: whether you are really being pursued, or would be prejudiced at trial or punished, because of race, religion, nationality, gender, sexual orientation or political opinions. A request for an ordinary crime can still be barred on the second ground.
Only when removal is imminent, the risk is of irreparable harm to a Convention right, and no domestic remedy with suspensive effect remains. The Court expects prima facie evidence of the risk, not mere hardship. Requests must arrive in good time: those received less than a working day before the scheduled removal may not be dealt with, and email is not accepted.
Under the rule of speciality in Article 14 of the European Convention on Extradition, you may not be proceeded against, sentenced or detained for other offences committed before surrender. The exceptions are the consent of the surrendering State, or your failure to leave within 45 days of final discharge, or your return after leaving.