Article 8 Explained: Private Life, Family, Home and Correspondence

A qualified right that the State may restrict only when an interference is lawful, pursues a listed aim and is necessary in a democratic society. How the test works and where it applies.

Send Us a Message
Human Rights Lawyers team

Article 8 of the European Convention on Human Rights protects four closely related interests: private life, family life, home and correspondence. Unlike the prohibition of torture, it is a qualified right. The State may interfere with it, but only if the interference meets the conditions set out in the article's second paragraph. This guide sets out the text, what each protected interest covers, how the justification test in Article 8(2) is structured, and how the article comes up in expulsion, extradition, INTERPOL and surveillance cases.

Pages of an old family photo album

The text of Article 8

The article, headed "Right to respect for private and family life", reads in the official text of the Convention:

  1. "Everyone has the right to respect for his private and family life, his home and his correspondence."
  2. "There shall be no interference by a public authority with the exercise of this right except such as is in accordance with the law and is necessary in a democratic society in the interests of national security, public safety or the economic well-being of the country, for the prevention of disorder or crime, for the protection of health or morals, or for the protection of the rights and freedoms of others."

Two features of the wording matter from the outset. The right is to "respect" for these interests, not an unlimited entitlement to them. And the second paragraph is addressed to interference "by a public authority": the article is a limit on what the State and its organs may do.

The four protected interests

The Convention does not define any of the four terms. Their scope has been worked out by the European Court of Human Rights case by case, so it is safer to think of them as headings than as closed categories.

Private life

Private life is the widest of the four headings. In everyday terms it points to the person's own sphere: identity, personal information and relationships with others. A measure that exposes, records or restricts a person can raise questions under it even where no family relationship or home is involved.

Family life

Family life concerns the relationships between family members and their ability to live together. It is the interest most often at stake when a State separates a family, for example by removing one member from the country where the others live.

Home

The home is protected as a place where a person lives. Measures by public authorities that affect it, such as entry, search or eviction, can raise questions under this heading.

Correspondence

Correspondence covers communications with others. Measures that open, read, intercept or record a person's communications can raise questions under this heading.

The Article 8(2) test: when an interference is justified

Because Article 8 is qualified, a complaint is usually analysed in steps that follow the wording of the article. Steps 1 and 2 decide whether Article 8 applies at all; if it does, the interference is justified only if steps 3 to 5 are all satisfied, and failure at any of them means a violation.

  1. Does the case fall within Article 8(1)? The complaint must concern private life, family life, home or correspondence.
  2. Has a public authority interfered with that interest? A decision, measure or act of the State must have affected it.
  3. Was the interference "in accordance with the law"? At a minimum, the interference must have a basis in domestic law. Where a measure has no legal basis, or goes beyond what the law permits, the analysis can stop here.
  4. Did it pursue a legitimate aim? The aim must be one of those listed in Article 8(2): national security, public safety, the economic well-being of the country, the prevention of disorder or crime, the protection of health or morals, or the protection of the rights and freedoms of others. The list is exhaustive in the text.
  5. Was it "necessary in a democratic society"? This is the stage at which the interests are weighed: the seriousness of the interference with the person's life against the importance of the aim pursued.

Because the last step involves weighing, preparing an Article 8 complaint means documenting the concrete effect of the measure on the person and the family, not only identifying a breach of procedure.

How Article 8 differs from Article 3

The contrast with Article 3 explains why Article 8 arguments are framed differently. Article 3 states that "no one shall be subjected to torture or to inhuman or degrading treatment or punishment" and contains no exceptions. In Saadi v. Italy the Grand Chamber rejected the argument that the risk of ill-treatment can be weighed against the interests of the community. Article 8, by contrast, expressly allows weighing through the words "necessary in a democratic society". Our guide to Article 3 and the ban on ill-treatment explains that side of the comparison.

The same difference appears in emergencies. Under Article 15, a State may derogate from its Convention obligations in time of war or other public emergency threatening the life of the nation, strictly to the extent required and with notice to the Secretary General of the Council of Europe. Article 15(2) lists the rights from which no derogation is permitted, among them Articles 2, 3, 4(1) and 7. Article 8 is not on that list.

Article 8 in typical cases

Expulsion and deportation

When a State decides to remove a person who has a family or an established private life in its territory, Article 8 can be engaged and the removal must then meet the Article 8(2) test. The State's aims, such as the prevention of disorder or crime, are weighed against the effect on the person and the family. Where the risk in the destination country amounts to ill-treatment, Article 3 applies, and no weighing is allowed. Our page on asylum and protection against removal covers how these arguments are raised in protection claims.

Extradition

Extradition can also interfere with private and family life. In the United Kingdom, the Extradition Act 2003 requires the judge to decide whether extradition is compatible with Convention rights within the meaning of the Human Rights Act 1998, which include Article 8: under section 21A for persons not convicted and section 21 for convicted persons in category 1 cases, and under section 87 in category 2 cases. If extradition would be incompatible, the person must be discharged. Section 21A also asks separately whether extradition would be disproportionate, having regard to the seriousness of the conduct, the likely penalty and the possibility of less coercive measures. These arguments are part of our work on challenging extradition on human-rights grounds.

INTERPOL notices

A Red Notice asks police worldwide to locate a person and to detain, arrest or restrict his or her movement for the purpose of extradition, surrender or similar lawful action. The publication of the notice and the processing of personal data can affect private life and the person's ability to travel. How Article 8 interacts with Articles 3, 5 and 6 in that setting is explained in our guide to human rights engaged by a Red Notice.

Surveillance and data

Interception of communications engages the "correspondence" and "private life" headings. Secret measures are by their nature hard for the person affected to see or contest, which makes the question whether they are "in accordance with the law" central. The State must also point to an aim from the Article 8(2) list, such as national security or the prevention of disorder or crime, and show that the interference was necessary in a democratic society.

Remedies and bringing an Article 8 complaint

Article 13 requires "an effective remedy before a national authority" for arguable Convention complaints, and Article 8 complaints must normally be raised at home first. Applicants in sensitive family or private-life cases can ask the Court to keep their identity confidential: anonymity must be requested with reasons, and the Court may authorise it. A complaint about a minor interference may also raise the admissibility question of whether the applicant suffered a significant disadvantage. For these and the other conditions, see our guide to ECHR admissibility criteria; for representation in an Article 8 application, our page on applications to the European Court describes what our team does at each stage.

Frequently Asked Questions

No. Article 8 is a qualified right. Its second paragraph allows a public authority to interfere where the interference is in accordance with the law, pursues one of the listed legitimate aims and is necessary in a democratic society. Article 3, by contrast, contains no exceptions, and the risk of ill-treatment cannot be weighed against community interests.

Article 8(2) lists them: national security, public safety, the economic well-being of the country, the prevention of disorder or crime, the protection of health or morals, and the protection of the rights and freedoms of others. An aim that is not on the list cannot justify the interference, however reasonable it may seem.

It can be relied on in both. Removal that separates a person from family or an established private life must satisfy the Article 8(2) test, and in UK extradition cases the judge must decide whether extradition is compatible with Convention rights. Because the right is qualified, the outcome depends on weighing the effect on the person against the State's aim.

Article 15 allows derogation in time of war or other public emergency threatening the life of the nation, strictly to the extent required by the situation. Article 8 is not among the rights listed in Article 15(2) as non-derogable, unlike Articles 2, 3, 4(1) and 7. Any derogation must be notified to the Council of Europe Secretary General.

Family life concerns relationships between family members and their ability to live together. Private life is wider and, in everyday terms, concerns the person's own sphere, including identity, personal information and relationships with others. The Convention does not define either term, and a single measure, such as a removal decision, can affect both at once.